Wednesday night the guys performed live for the first time and once again I was slightly disappointed. Maybe it was the nerves, song choices (there were some bad ones), but these performances made me more nervous that we're not going to find the perfect Idol. There weren't any wow moments. It comes down to song choice, song choice, song choice. Don't pick songs by these stylized performers: Coldplay, The Fray, One Republic, Adam Levine of Maroon 5, Jason Mraz. Theses guys who are on the radio all the time...you will always have a poor man's version of these songs. Don't pick predictable songs like "Don't Let the Sun Go Down on Me" by Elton John. It's been done a million times. Don't sing Stevie Wonder. Randy will hate it and tear you apart. Idols: watch the show. There are simple rules.
Since this show has started, I've sat from my couch wishing I was a song selection coach for American Idol. I wish that was a real job. Armchair Diva, SSC. So that's what I'm gonna be from my couch. And for the whole season, you are going to hear me suggesting songs I want these contestants to sing and ripping them for the poor ones they choose.
Here's what I thought of the guys:
Todrick Hall (Song Choice: Since U Been Gone)
Yes, that's right. "Since U Been Gone" by Kelly Clarkson. Seemed so strange to me. Do I love it? Do I hate it? I'm so confused. Yesterday, I thought it was okay, but today I think I hated it. I love a contestant who takes a risk, but this was too out there. You can't change a #1 hit by a former Idol winner so much it becomes unrecognizable. It was Indulgent city and far too risky. Simon said it was stupid, and that may seem extreme. I love that he said he heard in his head. It takes big balls to do what he did and you have to respect that. This kid can perform and is adorable, so hopefully he can come back and redeem himself next week and we can actually hear him sing.
Aaron Kelly (Song Choice: Here Comes Goodbye)
This kid is adorable. And I love anything by Rascal Flatts so he won me over big time. Not the best vocals in the world and he's so humble that America will fall in love with him. But to take on a song by this group and sung by Gary LeVox is a tall order. No one can sing quite like Gary, he has a very special voice. He hits notes most men can't hit. Hoping Aaron sticks around one more week at least. Not sure if he can sell out a crowd or walk a red carpet, but he's got Disney TV movie written all over him. There's definitely a market for him. Love his spikey little haircut, the smile, young girls will love him. He could be this year's Kevin "Chicken Little" Covais.
Jermaine Sellers (Song Choice: Get Here)
This guy with the suspenders and the different colored socks, shoes....I don't know this song and didn't learn to love it. Seems like a nice kid, I judged him based on his front suspenders at first, but his rendition of this Oleta Adams song was not good. Too much screaming, too many runs, just too much. He's in trouble. Maybe the jacket and the tails will help. But I doubt it.
Tim Urban (Song Choice: Apologize)
Can you say High School Musical??. Zac Efron Part II?? Adorable kid, great floppy Troy Bolton hair. Not a great singer. This is the perfect example of what I was talking about...If you don't have a falsetto, don't sing a song by Ryan Tedder. A One Republic song is a tall order unless you are David Archuleta or Kris Allen. Might be time to say goodbye to my little Disney TV movie star.
Joe Munoz (Song Choice: You and I)
Great choice of song and actually pulled off Jason Mraz. I love this song and he absolutley knew his voice and not to oversing the song. Only problem, he was in the middle of the pack and it didn't actually wow anyone. I was pleasantly surprised by Joe, after that piece where he kept forgetting his lyrics. I think a lose a few years off my live watching Idol waiting for them to remember their lyrics. Why is this so hard for them? I admit to being terrible with lyrics, I never know what I am singing. "Hold me closer Tony Danza".. yeah that's me with Tiny Dancer. But you better believe I am going to remember my lyrics when I only have 90 seconds to sing for the opportunity of a lifetime. Ever year... EVERY year this is a problem. I will never get it.
Tyler Grady (Song Choice: American Woman)
THIS guy.... Let's call him "The Chin". I've never seen anything like it. He gives Jay Leno a run for his money in the chin department. He's just so big, so blocky. Big head on such a lean body. Cute guy and likeable, but I'm intimidated by him. I can't really watch him and I'm thinking this is gonna be a problem. And forget the chin, I can't get passed the Vinny Barbarino wardrobe. He does look like he came out of a time machine and has posters of Jim Morrison and Farrah Fawcett on his bedroom walls. And American Woman was such an obvious choice for him. He needs to switch it up and do something unexpected. I'll keep him around for another week.
Lee DeWyze (Song Choice: Chasing Cars)
My favorite of the season based on about 20 seconds of an audition piece. He didn't get much air time, you didn't get to know his story, but as soon as I heard him sing, I knew he was goin to be my boy. He has that The Fray, James Morrison vibe which I love. Give a guy an acoustic guitar and a graphic tee-shirt and I'm in. I love Snow Patrol, but didn't really love the song "Chasing Cars" for his voice. I would've loved to see him sing a Gavin DeGraw song - "I Don't Wanna Be" (an Idol early audition fave) or "More Than Anyone". Hoping he sticks around next week to sing something like that. Something about this kid's eyes makes me like him. I love that he's humble. I agree with Simon, we should expect big things from Lee.
John Park (Song Choice: God Bless the Child)
This song should be banned from Idol. It's depressing, it's slow, it sucks. My immediate reaction was hotel lounge, hotel lounge, hotel lounge. This guy was Shania's favorite in the early audtions, and he can blow, but this was just the wrong song for him. It's the wrong song for everyone... unless you rock it like Micaela Gordon season 4, her best performance. John could be in trouble.
Michael Lynche (Song Choice: This Love)
This guy's a charmer and he had a nice back-story with his baby being born during the auditions, but the producers need to stop milking this story. It's getting annoying. It was risky to do a Maroon 5 song, Adam Levine owns that song. His big body was swallowing that little guitar; it looked like a uekele or a violin in his arms. He's just too scary big. Good chops, he's infectious, and America will love him. America always votes in that big loveable, teddy bear footbally player guy. I'm dubbing him this year's Michael Sarver (season 8) or season 2's Matthew Rogers.
Alex Lambert (Song Choice: Wonderful World)
I LOVE this song. Love James Morrison. I think this kid is adorable and quirky, and he has an amazing voice. He has raw talent, this rich tone to his voice. All that.. and zero stage presence. If you closed your eyes and listened it was great. But he was awkward in every move he made. Hoepfully he can get another chance and make up for it, but it might Alex's time to go.
Casey James (Song Choice: Heaven)
When I heard this guy was singing a Bryan Adams song, my first reaction was "Oh F*ck. Not another dreadful Bryan Adams song". I don't think I would've been able to take it if he sang "Summer of '69". I would've ran out of the room, buried my head in the pillow. That song would've been Idol suicide... can you say cover band? Well, that's what Simon would've said. I f*cking hate Bryan Adams. I really do. But really it's Bryan Adams post-Reckless I don't like. "Heaven", "Summer of '69", and "One Night Love Affair" are all good songs. But any of that Robin Hood crap, I just can't handle. I don't want anyone singing "Everything I Do" or "Have You Ever Really Loved a Woman". Hate hate hate those songs. Anything from Robin Hood or that damn Don Juan DeMarco. Unless you are Chris Daughtry or David Cook, you can't sing those songs. Ultimately, Casey James was the best of the night and sounded really good. I was a little embarrassed for him and uncomfortable with the Kara-Casey sexual tension. Brought back memories of season 2's Paula and Corey Clark controversy. Casey is like a good-looking Bo Bice, he is what America wanted Bo to be. I think America is realizing they had beer goggles on with that guy. Casey hould do very well in this competition. No doubt, Top 12.
Andrew Garcia (Song Choice: Sugar We're Going Down)
Andrew's performance was probably the most higly anticipated of the night (of course, he went last just like Katie Stevens did, another early favorite). And I think he disappointed. I loved the risk of taking a rock song by Fall Out Boy and making it acoustic, but some songs aren't meant to be switched up that much. Doesn't really matter though, America already fell in love with him after his acoustic rendition of Paula Abdul's "Straight Up" which would've made Paula proud. Hoping he leaves his guitar at home, and just takes the mic and sings next week. We'll be seeing him for many weeks to come.